Irish Geneaography
  • Welcome
    • Menu
  • Ingredients
    • Carving up the Landscape - Genealogical Geography >
      • Civil Geography >
        • Provinces & Counties
        • Townlands
      • Poor Law Unions
      • Civil Registration Districts
      • Census Geography
    • Main Dishes - Irish Church & Civil Records >
      • Roman Catholic Parishes & Registers
      • Church of Ireland Dioceses & Diocesan Records
      • Church of Ireland Parishes and Registers
      • Will Probate Districts & Records, 1858+
      • Civil Registration Records
    • Kitchen Garden - Irish Land Records >
      • 1798 Claimants & Surrenders
      • Tithe Applotment Books, 1823-1837 & Tithe Defaulters, 1831
      • Griffith's Valuation, 1847-1864
      • Valuation Revision Books, 1847-1864+
      • Return of Land Owners, 1876
      • Landed Estates Court Rentals, 1850-1880
      • Registry of Deeds (Land Leases, Marriage Settlements & Wills)
      • Irish Land Commission
    • Irish Maps & Gazetteers
    • Historical Directories
    • Irish Newspapers
    • Rules? What rules? Placenames & Boundaries
    • What's That - Glossary and Acronyms >
      • Acronyms
  • Recipes
    • What's for Dinner? Irish Genealogical Questions
    • Local Specialities - County Specific Resources >
      • Connaught >
        • Co. Galway >
          • Co. Galway CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Galway RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Leitrim >
          • Co. Leitrim CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Leitrim RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Mayo >
          • Co. Mayo CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Mayo RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Roscommon >
          • Co. Roscommon CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Roscommon RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Sligo >
          • Co. Sligo CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Sligo RoD Townland Indexes
      • Leinster >
        • Co. Carlow >
          • Co. Carlow CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Carlow RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Dublin & City of Dublin >
          • Co. & City of Dublin CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Dublin RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kildare >
          • Co. Kildare Church of Ireland Parish Records
          • Co. Kildare RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kilkenny >
          • Co. Kilkenny CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Kilkenny RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Laois (Queens County) >
          • Co. Laois (Queens County) CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Laois (Queens County) RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Longford >
          • Co. Longford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Longford RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Louth >
          • Co. Louth CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Louth & Drogheda RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Meath >
          • Co. Meath CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Meath RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Offaly (Kings County) >
          • Co. Offaly (Kings County) CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Offaly (Kings County) RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Westmeath >
          • Co. Westmeath CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Westmeath RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Wexford >
          • Co. Wexford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Wexford RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Wicklow >
          • Co. Wicklow CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Wicklow RoD Townland Indexes
      • Munster >
        • Co. Clare >
          • Co. Clare CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Clare RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Cork >
          • Co. Cork CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Cork RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kerry >
          • Co. Kerry CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Kerry RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Limerick >
          • Co. Limerick CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Limerick RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Tipperary >
          • Co. Tipperary CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Tipperary RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Waterford >
          • Co. Waterford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Waterford RoD Townland Indexes
      • Ulster >
        • Co. Antrim >
          • Co. Antrim CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Antrim & City of Belfast RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Armagh >
          • Co. Armagh CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Armagh RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Cavan >
          • Co. Cavan CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Cavan RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Derry >
          • Co. Derry CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Derry & City of Londonderry RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Donegal >
          • Co. Donegal CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Donegal RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Down >
          • Co. Down CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Down RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Fermanagh >
          • Co. Fermanagh CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Fermanagh RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Monaghan >
          • Co. Monaghan CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Monaghan RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Tyrone >
          • Co. Tyrone CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Tyrone RoD Townland Indexes
      • Northern Ireland
    • Restaurants - Irish Archives & Libraries >
      • The Registry of Deeds
      • The National Library of Ireland
      • The National Archives of Ireland
      • Dublin City Library and Archives
      • Valuation Office
      • Representative Church Body Library
      • Public Record Office of Northern Ireland
    • Dining Clubs - Societies & Journals
    • Special Ingredients - Unique Finding Aids >
      • Church of Ireland Parish Records Finder
      • Townland Indexes Timelines of LDS Registry of Deeds microfilms
    • Foreign Fare - Finding the Irish Abroad >
      • American Pie
      • Down Under
      • Settling under the Saltire
      • Fighting in a foreign field >
        • India
        • Europe, Middle East & Africa (WW1)
        • USA
    • Seasonings - Miscellaneous Sources >
      • Methodist Church in Ireland
      • Huguenots in Ireland
      • Monumental Inscriptions
      • Medical Men
      • Students, Clergy & Lawyers
      • Schoolbooks and Archive Notes
      • Dog Licences
      • Customs & Excise Officers
    • Kitchen Techniques - Tips & Advice >
      • Wildcard Searching for Placenames
      • Search tips for ScotlandsPeople
  • Cookbooks
    • Free Websites
    • Subscription / PPV Websites
    • Research Advice Websites & Videos
    • Blogs, Magazines & Forums
    • Bookshelves >
      • Guides & Finding Aids
      • Histories
      • Digital Libraries
  • Links
    • Snacks
    • Store Cupboard
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

Source Citations?  3...2...1... Now Argue!

11/3/2018

0 Comments

 
If there is one thing guaranteed to get 2 or more genealogists gathered together in a fankle, it's debating the rights and wrongs of how to construct correct source citations!  Whilst there are academic texts to help (Evidence Explained by Elizabeth Shown Mills of course being the first that springs to mind), people will inevitably come up with their own favourite way of citing evidence.  I use a pattern that I learned from my Postgraduate course which has proven to be reasonably robust and flexible, but evidently needs more work in some areas (see below!)  The various software packages we all mostly use to hold our data often have helpful "templates" for constructing particular types of sources, but a frequent criticism I have heard (and uttered myself) is that these tend to be biased towards American sources and are not always as helpful for sources from other parts of the world.

So, having recently enjoyed learning from several very good videos posted from Rootstech 2018, I am pleased to recommend one in particular that tackles this thorny subject well - "Source Citations - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly" by Diana Elder is well presented and nicely illustrated.  It certainly made me think more carefully about how good some of my source citations were.  I thought that layered citations was an interesting concept and one that would have helped solve a retrieval problem I had early this week when I was compiling my military research pages. 

I had some evidence from a source on Ancestry for a relative but when I tried to find the record again online to recommend the record collection, I could not locate it or indeed the collection?  I had failed my own test for a good source citation - it must contain ALL the necessary information in order to locate the EXACT record again.  Although, in my defence, I'm wondering if the record set has been absorbed into one of the other similarly named sets?  Nevertheless, I can see how I can improve how I cite the online evidence I gather, in particular that gained from the increasing number of microfilms that have been digitised for browsing - who wants to have to step through hundreds of pages again when you omitted the image number from your source citation?!  

Remember, for it to be a good source citation, you have to be able to find the same record again or tell someone else where they can find it - anything else is apparently bad or ugly!


0 Comments

Indexing the Indexes

9/3/2018

1 Comment

 
The sport of genealogy means forever being in quest of evidence that you know is there, believe is there or just hope is there.  Finding aids abound to help us and arguably, the most common finding aids we all use every day are indexes.  However, all indexes are not created equal as any indexer is as prone to making mistakes or interpreting atrocious or faded handwriting in a myriad of ways as you or I would be.  All of the big online data companies outsource the indexing of huge data sets to the lowest bidders around the globe and so we get various degrees of frustration or hilarity creeping into the data.  

So, let's take the Civil Registration Indexes for England & Wales (E&W) and for Ireland as 2 separate examples - both places you would expect to find lots of your Irish kin.

I recommend that you watch Audrey Collin's recent talk to Rootstech 2018 on how the E&W Civil Registration Indexes came to be created and you will appreciate just how easy it was for many errors to have crept into them well before any 20th century digital fingers started flying over keyboards to create the online indexes we all use today.  FreeBMD is a great free resource whereby volunteers are transcribing the GRO secondary indexes but did you know that there is also another volunteer project, UKBMD, that is focusing on local registrar indexes from which the GRO indexes were originally compiled (are you keeping up?!)  Find My Past (FMP) and Ancestry have then subsequently bought in some of these indexes and / or compiled their own.  That's a lot of different indexes starting to proliferate for the same records, so my advice is, if you can't find what you're hoping to find in one index, try out another one.

The free Irish government website, Irish Genealogy, has their own indexes to the Irish Civil Registration records, whilst I believe both FMP and Ancestry both bought in the index compiled by FamilySearch for the same records.  But it would appear from a recent story on Claire Santry's Irish Genealogy News blog that FMP have now created their own indexes to Irish civil births and marriages but there does seem to be some quality control issues.

Incidentally, I gather that perhaps somewhat unusually, FMP and Ancestry actually collaborated on the creation of new indexes to the Irish Roman Catholic records released by the National Library of Ireland - presumably to keep costs down rather than try to race each other to be first to publish?   So, if you are searching these records in either of these sites, I presume the results should be the same?  I haven't tested this one out for myself yet.

So, the moral of the tale is don't rely on just one index that happens to be accessible via your favourite free or subscription site.  If you want to be thorough and "reasonably exhaustive" in your research, then use as many different indexes as possible in order to compile your candidates.
1 Comment

    Author

    I'm Ruth and here are my own observations, good, bad and indifferent on all things geographically & genealogically Irish.

    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    September 2019
    May 2019
    August 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    August 2017
    June 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015

    Categories

    All
    Church Of Ireland
    National Archives Of Ireland
    New Content
    Online Resources
    Research Advice
    Research Stories
    Scotland

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.