Irish Geneaography
  • Welcome
    • Menu
  • Ingredients
    • Carving up the Landscape - Genealogical Geography >
      • Irish Civil Geography >
        • Provinces & Counties
        • Townlands
      • Irish Poor Law Unions >
        • Irish Poor Law Records
      • Irish Civil Registration Districts
      • Irish Census Geography
    • Main Dishes - Irish Church & Civil Records >
      • Irish Roman Catholic Parishes & Registers
      • Church of Ireland Dioceses & Diocesan Records
      • Church of Ireland Parishes and Registers
      • Irish Will Probate Districts & Records, 1858+
      • Irish Civil Registration Records
      • Public Records in Ireland
    • Kitchen Garden - Irish Land Records >
      • 1798 Claimants & Surrenders
      • Tithe Applotment Books, 1823-1837 & Tithe Defaulters, 1831
      • Griffith's Valuation, 1847-1864
      • Valuation Revision Books, 1847-1864+
      • Return of Land Owners, 1876
      • Landed Estates Court Rentals, 1850-1880
      • Registry of Deeds (Land Leases, Marriage Settlements & Wills)
      • Irish Land Commission
    • Irish Maps & Gazetteers
    • Historical Directories
    • Irish Newspapers
    • Rules? What rules? Placenames & Boundaries
    • What's That - Glossary and Acronyms >
      • Acronyms
  • Recipes
    • Local Specialities - County Specific Resources >
      • Connaught >
        • Co. Galway >
          • Co. Galway CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Galway RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Leitrim >
          • Co. Leitrim CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Leitrim RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Mayo >
          • Co. Mayo CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Mayo RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Roscommon >
          • Co. Roscommon CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Roscommon RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Sligo >
          • Co. Sligo CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Sligo RoD Townland Indexes
      • Leinster >
        • Co. Carlow >
          • Co. Carlow CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Carlow RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Dublin & City of Dublin >
          • Co. & City of Dublin CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Dublin RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kildare >
          • Co. Kildare Church of Ireland Parish Records
          • Co. Kildare RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kilkenny >
          • Co. Kilkenny CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Kilkenny RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Laois (Queens County) >
          • Co. Laois (Queens County) CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Laois (Queens County) RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Longford >
          • Co. Longford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Longford RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Louth >
          • Co. Louth CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Louth & Drogheda RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Meath >
          • Co. Meath CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Meath RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Offaly (Kings County) >
          • Co. Offaly (Kings County) CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Offaly (Kings County) RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Westmeath >
          • Co. Westmeath CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Westmeath RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Wexford >
          • Co. Wexford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Wexford RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Wicklow >
          • Co. Wicklow CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Wicklow RoD Townland Indexes
      • Munster >
        • Co. Clare >
          • Co. Clare CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Clare RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Cork >
          • Co. Cork CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Cork RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Kerry >
          • Co. Kerry CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Kerry RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Limerick >
          • Co. Limerick CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Limerick RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Tipperary >
          • Co. Tipperary CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Tipperary RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Waterford >
          • Co. Waterford CoI Parish Records
          • Co. & City of Waterford RoD Townland Indexes
      • Ulster >
        • Co. Antrim >
          • Co. Antrim CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Antrim & City of Belfast RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Armagh >
          • Co. Armagh CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Armagh RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Cavan >
          • Co. Cavan CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Cavan RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Derry >
          • Co. Derry CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Derry & City of Londonderry RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Donegal >
          • Co. Donegal CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Donegal RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Down >
          • Co. Down CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Down RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Fermanagh >
          • Co. Fermanagh CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Fermanagh RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Monaghan >
          • Co. Monaghan CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Monaghan RoD Townland Indexes
        • Co. Tyrone >
          • Co. Tyrone CoI Parish Records
          • Co. Tyrone RoD Townland Indexes
      • Northern Ireland
    • Special Ingredients - Unique Finding Aids >
      • Church of Ireland Parish Records Finder
      • Townland Indexes Timelines of LDS Registry of Deeds microfilms
    • Restaurants - Irish Archives & Libraries >
      • The Registry of Deeds >
        • The Registry of Deeds - History & Future
        • The Registry of Deeds - Visiting the Archive
        • The Registry of Deeds - Online Access
        • The Registry of Deeds - Finding Deeds
        • The Registry of Deeds - Deciphering and Citing a Deed
      • The National Library of Ireland
      • The National Archives of Ireland
      • Dublin City Library and Archives
      • Valuation Office
      • Representative Church Body Library
      • Public Record Office of Northern Ireland
    • Dining Clubs - Irish Societies & Journals
    • Chefs - Irish Genies
    • Foreign Fare - Finding the Irish Abroad >
      • American Pie - USA
      • Empire Builders - Canada
      • Down Under - Australia & New Zealand
      • Settling under the Saltire - Scotland >
        • Scottish History
        • Scottish Geography
        • Scottish Records & Resources
        • Scottish Research Bookshelf
        • Scottish Larder
        • Scottish Tuckbox
      • Fighting in a foreign field >
        • India
        • Europe, Middle East & Africa (WW1)
        • USA
    • Seasonings - Miscellaneous Sources >
      • Methodist Church in Ireland
      • Huguenots in Ireland
      • Medical Practitioners
      • Students, Clergy & Lawyers
      • Schoolbooks and Archive Notes
      • Irish Dog Licences
      • Customs & Excise Officers
    • Kitchen Techniques - Tips & Advice >
      • Wildcard Searching for Placenames
      • Search tips for ScotlandsPeople
      • Searching Scottish Parishes on ScotlandsPeople
      • Searching the NAI Testamentary Index
      • Searching the Inland Revenue Testamentary Indexes
      • Using the Irish Townland and Historical Map Viewer
  • Cookbooks
    • Free Websites
    • Subscription / PPV Websites
    • Research Advice Websites & Videos
    • Blogs, Magazines & Forums
    • Bookshelves >
      • Guides & Finding Aids
      • Histories
      • Digital Libraries
      • Bookmarks
  • Links
    • Snacks
    • Store Cupboard
    • Midnight Feasts >
      • Hunting for Irish Births
      • Hunting for Irish Baptisms
      • Hunting for Irish Marriages
      • Hunting for Irish Deaths
      • Hunting for Irish Burials
      • Hunting for Irish Monumental Inscriptions
      • Hunting for Irish Wills
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

"Dr. Watson in the Library with the Family Bible!" - become an objective detective!

26/11/2021

1 Comment

 
PictureRuss Stutler - http://www.stutler.cc/other/misc/baker_street.html
Those of you of a certain age i.e. as old as me, will recognise a genealogical nod towards the great reveal in the classic Cluedo board game in my post title.  If you've never played it, the object was to gather evidence as you made your way around the board, challenging fellow players with searching questions until you believed you had deduced killer, location and weapon i.e. forensically applying logic to solve the crime. 

​Which is pretty much what we need to be doing every time we encounter new characters and new evidence in our family history research. I was reminded of the wisdom of playing "objective detective" when I recently responded to a request for help.

One of the best questions that you can ask of any evidence that you are not sure of is "What would have to be true for this not to be my ancestor?"   Let me explain how trying to answer this question can help guide your research.

So, in the case of this particular family, we were seeking an ancestor's burial place and needed to establish the right death record and start our hunt from there.  One man dying in the Waterford workhouse in 1903 was promising and we did also have his usual townland from the record.  However, the surname was not uncommon in the area.  A perfectly feasible alternative scenario could have been that this was a similarly named cousin of our man of about the same age who had come to stay with the family and fallen ill?  Back to the 1901 censuses and an exercise in family reconstruction was needed.  Ironically, this same census revealed another man of the same name and age living in another similarly named townland but in another part of Co. Waterford!  Logically, if he was going to die in a workhouse, it ought to have been his local one which was not Waterford City.  Still, it would be a good idea to follow him forward from 1901 and "kill him off" separately to be certain.

What if our man hadn't died in Ireland?  Perhaps he had emigrated, hoping to bring his young family to join him but had disappeared or died whilst abroad?  This would need a lot of work trawling through passenger lists and any available overseas censuses or deaths. 

I can't say that we definitively solved this particular people puzzle, but by being forensically rigorous, we could at least support our tentative conclusions thus far.  A famous Sherlock Holmes quote states that "Whenever you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable must be the truth."  However, as we all know, genealogical evidence is often far from complete and we always wonder what other evidence might be out there that we haven't found or perhaps never survived that would contradict our conclusions.  In the meantime, when you think you have found something promising, ask yourself that searching question and test the alternative scenarios.

1 Comment
Augusta Lemon
28/11/2021 09:38:39 am

Great blog and a good example of how to be really methodical in research. Thank you!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I'm Ruth and here are my own observations, good, bad and indifferent on all things geographically & genealogically Irish.

    Archives

    September 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    July 2021
    April 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    September 2019
    May 2019
    August 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    August 2017
    June 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015

    Categories

    All
    Church Of Ireland
    National Archives Of Ireland
    New Content
    Online Resources
    Research Advice
    Research Stories
    Scotland

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.